Uncommon Goods | Custom Puzzles for all ages and interests 2025

We're partnering with Breastcancer.org for the month of October: Oct. 13-19, we'll donate $5 when you select them at checkout. (At no cost to you!) SHOP NOW

Skip to main content

Custom Puzzles for all ages and interests

Piece together your favorite memories with this personalized puzzle collection. Perfect for a cozy night in or a fun family activity.

  • Item not in your wishlist
    CustomizableCustom Lake Art Cribbage Board$79.00
    4.8 stars out of 5 1174
  • Item not in your wishlist
    CustomizableCustom Name Cribbage Pegs$30.00 - $40.00
    5 stars out of 5 6
  • Item not in your wishlist
    CustomizableCustom Icon Cribbage Pegs$30.00 - $40.00
    4.8 stars out of 5 5
  • Item not in your wishlist
    CustomizablePersonalized Tic Tac Toe$18.00 - $55.00
    4.9 stars out of 5 31
  • Item not in your wishlist
    Handmade Dice Tower$75.00
    4.4 stars out of 5 5
  • Item not in your wishlist
    Low StockEducational Surprise Bath Fizzies - Set of 5$35.00
    4.9 stars out of 5 37
  • Item not in your wishlist
    Snakes of Wrath Tile-Laying Game$60.00
    not yet rated

1 - 32 (of 32 items)

Discover unique custom puzzle sets that make the perfect personalized gift for any occasion. These custom puzzles are a fun and creative way to showcase your favorite memories and designs.

Looking for more one-of-a-kind gifts? Check out these other options:

Perpetual Calendar | Backyard Games | Beach Jewelry | Murder Mystery Party Supplies | Unique Chocolate Gifts

What are they into?

Select all that apply

Anything else?

Shop our suggestions

What makes us uncommon

forever returns

forever returns

if you don't love it, return it anytime

free shipping

free shipping

for Uncommon Perks members

independent makers

independent makers

creating innovative designs

better to give

better to give

over $3 million donated

B corp

founding b-corp

since 2007

no leather, featers, or fur

No leather, feathers, or fur

since our founding in 1999