Gifts for Mystery Lovers - Puzzling and Literary Items

Unravel the excitement with this collection of gifts for mystery lovers! From secret message pens to detective-themed puzzles, this assortment is sure to keep them on their toes. Perfect for those who love a good whodunit and a dash of intrigue!

SubscriptionScience Lovers Mystery Box Subscription$135.00 - $255.00
4.8 stars out of 5 5
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with Uncommon Perks
customers also bought
The Cat Year: A Year Of Kitty Companionship$22.00
4 stars out of 5 1
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with Uncommon Perks
customers also bought
80's Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle: Dognapped!$20.00
not yet rated
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with Uncommon Perks
customers also bought
Low StockReveal the Custom Message Mystery Game$17.00
5 stars out of 5 3
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with Uncommon Perks
customers also bought
How To Speak Cat Cards$10.00
4.9 stars out of 5 31
ships free with Uncommon Perks
customers also bought
Legends of the National Parks$35.00
4.9 stars out of 5 8
ships free with Uncommon Perks
customers also bought
Master Theorem Book of Puzzles$30.00
4.9 stars out of 5 59
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with Uncommon Perks
customers also bought
A Blind Date with A Book$19.00
4 stars out of 5 8
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with Uncommon Perks
customers also bought
Hidden Horror Jump Scare Jigsaw Puzzle$22.00
not yet rated
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with Uncommon Perks
customers also bought
Curious Correspondence: Puzzle Escape Room Games$40.00
not yet rated
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with Uncommon Perks
customers also bought
New!Murdle Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle$20.00
not yet rated
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with Uncommon Perks
customers also bought
2 Left!Death for Dinner Horror Movie Cookbook$25.00
5 stars out of 5 5
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with Uncommon Perks
customers also bought
Solve The Case Escape Room$20.00
3.5 stars out of 5 11
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with Uncommon Perks
customers also bought
Jane Austen's Plight – Escape Room Game$15.00
5 stars out of 5 1
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with Uncommon Perks
customers also bought
Unlock the Beer Escape Room$30.00
2.3 stars out of 5 6
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with Uncommon Perks
customers also bought
SubscriptionVictorian Era Detective Trilogy Subscription$100.00
5 stars out of 5 1
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with Uncommon Perks
customers also bought
Unlock the Wine Escape Room Game$28.00
4.3 stars out of 5 28
ships free with Uncommon Perks
customers also bought
Future Bookworm Literary Building Blocks$28.00
not yet rated
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with Uncommon Perks
customers also bought
Phone Jail Escape Room Game$30.00
4 stars out of 5 7
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with Uncommon Perks
customers also bought
Unlock the Whiskey Escape Room$28.00
4.3 stars out of 5 28
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with Uncommon Perks
customers also bought
New!Brass Cannon Sequential Puzzle$25.00
not yet rated
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with Uncommon Perks
customers also bought
Repurposed Climbing Rope Cozy$25.00
4.8 stars out of 5 5
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with Uncommon Perks
customers also bought
Sommify: A Blind Wine Tasting Board Game$50.00
5 stars out of 5 2
Usually ships within 24 hrs
ships free with Uncommon Perks
customers also bought
Gift SetMost Puzzling Gift Set of Brainteasers$68.00
5 stars out of 5 1
ships free with Uncommon Perks
customers also bought

1 - 24 (of 24 items)

similar categories

gifts for trivia lovers: unique finds and curiosities for quiz enthusiasts

gifts for book lovers & writers

find unique and fun puzzle gifts for puzzle lovers

valentine's day gifts for book lovers

Discover unique gifts for mystery lovers that will keep them guessing and engaged for hours. From intriguing puzzles to clever games, find the perfect present for those who love a good mystery.

Looking for more one-of-a-kind gifts? Check out these other options:

Pickleball Tournament Prizes | Attract Bees And Butterflies | Truth Or Dare Game For Couples | Personalized Birthday Newspaper | Ski Themed Gifts

What makes us uncommon

forever returns

forever returns

if you don't love it, return it anytime

free shipping

for Uncommon Perks members

independent makers

independent makers

creating innovative designs

better to give

over $3 million donated

founding b-corp

since 2007

no leather, featers, or fur

No leather, feathers, or fur

since our founding in 1999