Uncommon Goods | Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle – 500 Pieces, Games & Puzzles Gift

Perks members always get FREE shipping. Join today.

Skip to main content
Item not in your wishlist
Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle - The Collector
Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle - The Collector
Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle - The Collector
customer photos
Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle - The Collector thumbnail 1Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle - The Collector thumbnail 2Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle - The Collector thumbnail 3
customer photos

Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle – The Collector, 500 Pieces – Games & Puzzles Gift

This mystery puzzle turns every piece into a clue and every puzzler into a private eye.

$20.00

Shipping to 11220change

Arrives Tue, Nov 25 - Wed, Nov 26 Order within  00:00:00

Learn more

Arrival estimate is based on Standard shipping to the zip code provided. Other ship methods with different arrival dates are available in checkout.

Free forever returnsdetails

Exclusive

What Makes It Uncommon

Put on your thinking cap and pour yourself a cup of something eye-opening, because there’s a mystery to piece together. Reginald Audley, famed curator of curiosities and collector of the bizarre, has met an untimely—and suspicious—end. Fortunately, the brilliant detective Medea Thorne is on the case, and she could use a clever companion. That’s your cue. This mystery puzzle invites you into a world of secrets, storytelling, and striking visuals, offering a brain-tickling challenge with every twist and turn.

  • Assemble the puzzle to reveal a complete mystery filled with clues, characters, and curious twists.
  • For solo sleuths or collaborative puzzle-solving with friends and family.
  • Combines classic jigsaw fun with the thrill of an immersive murder mystery.
  • 500 pieces.
  • Made in China.

Key Features

  • 500-Piece Challenge - Engaging jigsaw with hidden clues and twists.
  • Paper Construction - Quality pieces with vivid, story-rich artwork.
  • Interactive Mystery - Assemble to uncover characters, evidence, and solution.
  • Solo or Group Play - Fun brainteaser for friends and family.
  • Exclusive Find - Only-at-Uncommon-Goods puzzle for mystery lovers.
  • Gift For Games & Puzzles Fans
  • Gift For Mystery Lovers
  • Gift For Teen Puzzle Enthusiasts
  • Gift For Family Game Nights
  • Gift For Bookish Sleuths

Usually ships within 24 hours.

See all shipping options and costs

Shipping outside of the U.S.? You will be quoted a specific delivery timeframe at checkout, based on your destination country and the available shipping methods. See International FAQ for more info.

Uncommon Perks

Get unlimited FAST, FREE SHIPPING (and other good stuff) with a 14-day free trial of Perks.

join uncommon perks

Sadly, we are unable to ship to APO, FPO, or DPO addresses at this time. We are working towards a solution that will allow us to resume this type of shipping.

Need to return? Free returns are accepted forever—no time limits. Within 30 days of delivery, refunds to the original payment method will be available. After 30 days, refunds will be processed to a digital gift card. See our return policy for more details.


Made from

paper

Measurements

9" L x 7" W x 2.5" H; 500 pieces

Item ID

60718

Still haven't found the details you're looking for? Check out our Product Q&A!

  • 5 stars out of 5

    Got this as a birthday gift for my mom- who loves puzzles and mystery

    read full review

  • 5 stars out of 5

    This is such a fun twist on a regular jigsaw puzzle. I normally am a s

    read full review

  • 5 stars out of 5

    ​This puzzle is fantastic for cognitive health. The act of piecing tog

    read full review


4.78
4.78 stars out of 5
based on 9 reviews
100%
of respondents would
recommend this to a friend
5 stars
8 users rating this 5 stars
4 stars
0 users rating this 4 stars
3 stars
1 users rating this 3 stars
2 stars
0 users rating this 2 stars
1 star
0 users rating this 1 star

Love!! Perfect gift for a mystery-lover

Got this as a birthday gift for my mom- who loves puzzles and mystery books/shows - so it was the perfect combo. She LOVED it. It took her some time to do, and was so well made and a fun storyline. The quality was great as well! Highly recommend #sweepstakes


A must for all puzzle lovers

This is such a fun twist on a regular jigsaw puzzle. I normally am a solo puzzle solver, this was so much fun to do in a group. It's you like Clue (the game or the movie) you will absolutely love this puzzle. I would buy more puzzles in this style for sure.


Engaging Mystery Puzzle

​This puzzle is fantastic for cognitive health. The act of piecing together the visual clues, combined with solving the overarching mystery, greatly boosts problem-solving skills and sustained focus. It requires intense concentration to connect the visual patterns while simultaneously tracking the story, making it a powerful way to keep the brain active and sharp. If you love a good whodunit and want a brainteaser that goes beyond simple assembly, this is a must-have!"


So Much Fun!

This puzzle was such a cool twist on a regular jigsaw. The final image is a secret until you finish, which made it feel like solving a mystery as I went. The pieces are good quality, the artwork is detailed, and it kept me hooked the whole way through. Perfect mix of challenge and fun...I'd totally recommend it!


Fun Gift Idea!

I love this puzzle concept. It is so interesting that the clues are what help to create the puzzle. It is the best of both worlds for those who like puzzles and mysteries. This makes a great gift when you want to give something different and creative.


I would buy from this brand again!

This puzzle was perfect for a chill date night. I think the key is to thoroughly read the story/clues, and have the right music to set the mood. We had a good time piecing it together!


Such a Fun Product!

I was so glad receive this puzzle. It's right up my alley with puzzles, books and murder mysteries! The box is carefully crafted, and I love how the puzzle pieces come in their own bag. I haven't gotten a chance to put it together yet, but when I do, I'm going to have so much fun!


A Puzzle and Mystery in One!

The Murder Most Puzzling: Death of a Collector Puzzle is such a fun twist on a classic jigsaw. As you build, you uncover hidden clues to solve the mystery, making it way more engaging than a regular puzzle. The pieces are sturdy, the artwork is clever, and I love the eco-friendly packaging. A great gift for puzzle and mystery lovers alike!


Great family activity

Received this great puzzle. Love that there is a mystery in solving it! Nice packaging and delivered quickly. Can not wait to get to work to complete it.


photos from reviews

  • Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle - The Collector from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.
  • Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle - The Collector from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.
  • Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle - The Collector from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.
  • Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle - The Collector from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.
  • Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle - The Collector from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.
  • Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle - The Collector from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.
  • Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle - The Collector from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.
  • Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle - The Collector from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.

Got questions? Find your answers here

How many pieces are in the puzzle?

It includes 500 pieces for a satisfying, intermediate challenge.


What is this puzzle made of?

The jigsaw is made of paper with printed artwork.


Is it meant for solo or group play?

Designed for solo sleuths or collaborative solving with friends and family.


Does the puzzle include a mystery to solve?

Yes—assemble the puzzle to reveal clues, characters, and a full whodunit.


Where is the puzzle made?

Made in China.



As the holidays approach, it's the perfect time to gather around with family and friends, piecing together not just puzzles, but also cherished memories. With every twist and turn, you'll be creating festive moments that will last a lifetime. For more inspiration, check out our selection of unique Christmas gifts that bring joy and surprise to your loved ones.

When it comes to finding the right gift, it’s all about connecting with what makes your loved ones smile. Whether you’re shopping for a puzzle enthusiast or someone who loves a good mystery, our gifting team has you covered. Explore our wide array of gifts for men and gifts for women to find that perfect surprise that will light up their holiday season.