Item not in your wishlist
Premium Custom Puzzle Sorting Trays
Premium Custom Puzzle Sorting Trays
Premium Custom Puzzle Sorting Trays
Premium Custom Puzzle Sorting Trays
Premium Custom Puzzle Sorting Trays
Premium Custom Puzzle Sorting Trays

Premium Custom Puzzle Sorting Trays

Handmade walnut trays with a felted touch, built for puzzlers who sort in style and slide with ease.

$42.00 - $130.00

  • Unlimited fast, free shipping
  • Add your 14-day free trial
  • Two $5 promo codes every year
Perks

Delivery dates vary, select an item for an arrival estimate

Handmade

Independent Maker

Made in USA

What Makes Premium Custom Puzzle Sorting Trays Uncommon

Puzzle chaos meets well-sorted calm. These premium walnut sorting trays were made for puzzlers who like their edge pieces organized, their colors grouped, and their workspace as polished as their problem-solving. Each tray features a smooth felt inlay in one of five modern hues, plus a smart sloped edge so you can slide pieces out like a pro when it’s time to lock them in. Available in three sizes or a complete set of all three, these trays can even be personalized—think last names, nicknames, or puzzle puns, up to 20 characters per tray.

Check out the matching Handmade Walnut Puzzle Lid Stand—it’s a smart (and stylish) addition to any puzzle setup.

  • Handcrafted from rich walnut wood with a soft felt inlay for quiet, secure sorting.
  • Choose from five stylish felt colors: Dark Grey, Light Grey, Dark Teal, Burnt Orange, and Green.
  • Features a gently sloped edge for easily sliding pieces from tray to puzzle board.
  • Available individually in Small (9.5"), Medium (11.5"), or Large (13.5") sizes, or as a complete set of three.
  • Personalized sets allow for unique custom text (up to 20 characters) on each of the three trays.
  • Handmade in Texas.
Victoria and Scott Bray

created by

Victoria and Scott Bray

Creating is a family affair for husband and wife duo Scott and Victoria Bray. The two met in Las Vegas while pursuing respective careers in sound engineering and design. Scott's woodworking journey began by building theater sets, while Victoria's started in elementary workshops. Moving to Texas in 2012, the couple combined their passions, building their first card holder for their small children. Victoria now leads the design channels of their business, while Scott focuses on engineering.

This is a made-to-order item that ships directly from the maker. If you order today your item will ship no later than 10/7/2026.

Items that are made to order or oversized can't be sent in a Gift Bag. Instead, you can include your Gift Message on the shipment's packing slip. 

At this time, this item cannot be shipped to APO/FPO addresses, P.O. Boxes, or to U.S. Territories including Minor Outlyling Islands. Contact custom@uncommongoods.com with any questions.

This item is not available to ship outside of the U.S. See International FAQ for more info.

Made-to-order and customized items are not returnable unless damaged or defective. See our return policy for more details.

What are the puzzle sorting trays made from?

wool felt, walnut, walnut mdf

What are the puzzle sorting trays' measurements?

Small: 9.5" L x 9.5" W x .75" H; Medium: 11.5" L x 11.5" W x.75" H Large: 13.5" L x 13.5" W x .75" H

How do you care for the puzzle sorting trays?

Wipe with clean cloth

Item ID

62069

Still haven't found the details you're looking for? Check out our Product Q&A!

Customers also bought

Also by Victoria and Scott Bray

similar categories

Every list has one person who is impossible to shop for, and the holidays are when that becomes a problem. A puzzle or a game is one of the few gifts the whole room ends up using. Our thoughtful Christmas gifts cover everyone from close family to the office gift exchange.

It helps to start from the recipient and work backwards to the present. Browse our gifts for men and gifts for women for whoever is left.