Uncommon Goods | New York Times Custom Front Page Puzzle | Front Page History Puzzle

We're partnering with Breastcancer.org for the month of October: Oct. 13-19, we'll donate $5 when you select them at checkout. (At no cost to you!) SHOP NOW

Skip to main content
Item not in your wishlist
New York Times Custom Front Page Puzzle
New York Times Custom Front Page Puzzle
New York Times Custom Front Page Puzzle
New York Times Custom Front Page Puzzle
customer photos
New York Times Custom Front Page Puzzle thumbnail 1New York Times Custom Front Page Puzzle thumbnail 2New York Times Custom Front Page Puzzle thumbnail 3New York Times Custom Front Page Puzzle thumbnail 4
customer photos

New York Times Custom Front Page Puzzle

Celebrate a significant day by turning a front-page story into leisurely fun.

$55.00 - $75.00

Unique gift Personalized experience Challenging puzzle Great quality Memorable keepsake Fun activity Perfect for milestones

Delivery dates vary, select an item for an arrival estimate

If your gift will arrive late, let them know it's on the way – and worth the wait.

Made in USA

What Makes It Uncommon

Seize the Day

Your favorite history buff is always attempting to put the pieces together. Celebrate their (or your) special day—birthday, anniversary, milestone—with this puzzle, an interactive memento made from the New York Times front page (since 1851) of your choice. Comprised of 500 pieces, the puzzles are made in Williston, Vermont.

This is a made-to-order item that ships directly from the maker. If you order today your item will ship no later than 10/20/2025.

Items that are made to order or oversized can't be sent in a Gift Bag. Instead, you can include your Gift Message on the shipment's packing slip.  At this time, this item cannot be shipped to APO/FPO addresses, P.O. Boxes, or to U.S. Territories including Minor Outlyling Islands. Contact custom@uncommongoods.com with any questions.

Shipping outside of the U.S.? You will be quoted a specific delivery timeframe at checkout, based on your destination country and the available shipping methods. See International FAQ for more info.

Made-to-order and customized items are not returnable unless damaged or defective. See our return policy for more details.


Ages

12+

Made from

paperboard

Measurements

Completed 500 pc Puzzle: 19" L x 13.5" W;
Completed 1000 pc Puzzle: 27" L x 19" W

Care

Avoid moisture.

Notes

Keep in mind that historic events usually appeared in the paper the day AFTER the date of the event.

Some front pages are unavailable due to a newspaper strike or a lack of relevant information on the front page for that date. These may be supplemented with front pages from other sections or regions. Please review all date restrictions to see if your date is impacted.

Pages after 1998 are in full color.

The dimensions of Times pages have changed several times since 1851. To make the front page fit properly without distortion, there may be a special border along the edges of your puzzles. The border helps make the puzzles unique while preserving the integrity of the Times' front pages.

Once your order is submitted it enters into production; changes or cancellations cannot be accommodated- we are sorry, no exceptions. Production begins immediately. All Orders Final.

Item ID

42300

Still haven't found the details you're looking for? Check out our Product Q&A!

Unique gift Personalized experience Challenging puzzle Great quality Memorable keepsake Fun activity Perfect for milestones

People love this product for its unique and personalized nature, making it a memorable gift that provides a fun and challenging experience.

AI generated summary

  • 5 stars out of 5

    I WASN'T LOOKING FOR A "BIRTHDAY" PUZZLE, HOWEVER I CAME ACROSS THIS W

    read full review

  • 5 stars out of 5

    I WASN'T LOOKING FOR A "BIRTHDAY" PUZZLE, HOWEVER I CAME ACROSS THIS W

    read full review

  • 5 stars out of 5

    Purchased this for my wife's( a jigsaw puzzle lover) birthday, and it

    read full review


4.84
4.84 stars out of 5
based on 198 reviews
97%
of respondents would
recommend this to a friend
5 stars
173 users rating this 5 stars
4 stars
20 users rating this 4 stars
3 stars
4 users rating this 3 stars
2 stars
1 users rating this 2 stars
1 star
0 users rating this 1 star

I would not buy this product again

This is the fourth NYT front page puzzle I bought. Each one was laid out differently and the puzzle did not match the picture. The NYT border was at the bottom instead of the side as the picture indicated and the front page is getting smaller which makes it difficult to read the print. I will never buy one this size again

Response from merchant

Thank you for taking the time to share your feedback. I'm really sorry to hear that the layout of your latest New York Times front page puzzle didn’t match the preview image, and that the changing design and smaller print made for a disappointing experience. We truly appreciate your continued support of your previous purchases. Your feedback is very helpful and will be shared with our product team for review. We’ve reached out directly to offer more help.


Extra, Extra, Read All About It...

I WASN'T LOOKING FOR A "BIRTHDAY" PUZZLE, HOWEVER I CAME ACROSS THIS WHILE SCROLLING IN THE BIRTHDAY DROP DOWN. UNIQUE, FUN, & FRAMEABLE - MAKING THE NY TIMES CUSTOM FRONT PAGE PUZZLE AN "UNCOMMON" KEEPSAKE! I WOULD DEFINITELY PURCHASE AGAIN FOR OTHER BIRTHDAYS. #sweepstakes


EXTRA, EXTRA, READ ALL ABOUT IT!

I WASN'T LOOKING FOR A "BIRTHDAY" PUZZLE, HOWEVER I CAME ACROSS THIS WHILE SCROLLING IN THE BIRTHDAY DROP DOWN. UNIQUE, FUN, & FRAMEABLE - MAKING THE NY TIMES CUSTOM FRONT PAGE PUZZLE AN "UNCOMMON" KEEPSAKE! I WOULD DEFINITELY PURCHASE AGAIN FOR OTHER BIRTHDAYS.


The PERFECT birthday gift

Purchased this for my wife's( a jigsaw puzzle lover) birthday, and it was a complete hit! Seriously, if you have a puzzle lover in your life, you can't go wrong with this!


THE PERFECT GIFT

A unique, high quality, personalized gift for a puzzle-lover, a hard-to-buy-for friend/relative, co- worker, really any/everyone with interesting history


Gift for my mom

Mom loved this puzzle! Recommended for friends and family that enjoy jigsaw puzzles.


Excellent Anniversary Gift

I gave this to my parents for their 60th wedding anniversary. They love doing puzzles and really enjoyed seeing the headlines from that special day. They also said they could read the typeset as well, it was not blurry. I got the puzzle with the most pieces as that is their difficulty level and it was perfect. Very "uncommon" gift, which is exactly what was needed for a couple in their 80s that has been married 60 years!


Will buy the right date next year!!

Was nice father in law enjoyed it but unfortunately got his birthdate wrong.


Excellent

I bought one for myself & my husband's birthdays. Will frame. I have inherited artwork I'll donate to a charity as I like these better - more personal.


Too difficult to match words

I bought the 1000 piece puzzle as a birthday gift for my puzzle loving mother. There weren't many pictures on the front page the day she was born. It is nearly impossible to finish! It's such a cool gift idea, but don't get the 1000 piece version! Even the 500 piece version would be tough for her birthdate! And definitely order a magnifying glass to go with it!

Response from merchant

Hello! Thank you for your feedback! We're sorry to hear the puzzle has proven to be more difficult than anticipated. We definitely recommend the magnifying glass to help match up the print!


photos from reviews

  • New York Times Custom Front Page Puzzle from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.
  • New York Times Custom Front Page Puzzle from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.
  • New York Times Custom Front Page Puzzle from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.
  • New York Times Custom Front Page Puzzle from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.
  • New York Times Custom Front Page Puzzle from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.
  • New York Times Custom Front Page Puzzle from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.
  • New York Times Custom Front Page Puzzle from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.

I recently purchased a frame from you for a New York Times Puzzle. I have ordered this from you 3 other times in the past. On the website for ordering for the puzzle, it says that the width is 13", however when I finally finished putting it together, I discovered that this is not true. It is slightly larger. I measured one of my other frames that I received from you. It measures as ~13.25". I was wondering if you have a record of my prior frame orders from you. Did I request a slightly larger width than 13"? I am just not sure what to do now. I kind of remember we had a discussion in the past about the dimensions. Can you please check on this for me. Thank you so much.

Verified reply from Iriscelis

The New York Times Custom Front Page 500 piece Puzzle is 19" L x 13.5" W once assembled. The item page has been updated to reflect the correct size. We apologize for any confusion this may have caused.


How come some dates are unavailable me? I'm looking for 9/24/78 but it says nothing is available.

Verified reply from Robert

We're sorry. This date is not available due to the New York City newspaper strike of 1978. During this time, no newspapers were published from August 10, 1978 to November 5, 1978.


Does the puzzle come with a picture of the finished product?

Verified reply from Alice

Yes it does!


What size box does it come in

Verified reply from Alice

The box measurements are 9" L x 7" W x 1" H.



This gift is great for ...

  • Friends Who Enjoy Puzzles

  • Partners Who Cherish Memories

  • Couples Who Love History

  • Adults Who Appreciate Unique Gifts


Our gifting team believes that every significant occasion deserves to be celebrated in a memorable way. This custom front-page puzzle makes for a unique gift that can spark joy and nostalgia during the holidays. If you're looking for more unique Christmas gifts that can bring families closer together and create lasting memories, check out our collection of thoughtful Christmas gifts to brighten up your festive season.

Finding the right gift can be a challenge, but personal touches make all the difference. Whether you're shopping for a history buff or someone who loves puzzles, our gifting experts recommend a variety of options that cater to everyone. Explore our selection of gifts for men and gifts for women to ensure your gift is as unique as the person receiving it!