Uncommon Goods | Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle | Puzzles
Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle
Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle
Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle
customer photos

big chillin’ 🎞️ • #vsco

Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle thumbnail 1Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle thumbnail 2Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle thumbnail 3
customer photos

big chillin’ 🎞️ • #vsco

Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle

Complete each 500 piece jigsaw to reveal the clues and solve the mystery.

$17.00

Great gift Fun activity Challenging puzzle Unique experience Mystery aspect Family bonding Creative design

Shipping to 11220 change location

Arrives Tue, Jul 22 - Wed, Jul 23

Order within 00:00:00

Learn more

Arrival estimate is based on Standard shipping to the zip code provided. Other ship methods with different arrival dates are available in checkout.

What Makes It Uncommon

*Shriek!* Brace yourself, there's been...a murder. And it's up to you to solve the crime, piece by piece. Elegance meets a touch of the macabre in these mysterious and absorbing puzzles. Begin by reading the story of the incident. Then, guided by the narrative rather than a visual reference, complete the jigsaw. The finished image provides all the clues you need to decipher whodunit. Choose your adventure:

  • The Clairvoyants’ Convention: Someone’s been strangled at the international clairvoyants’ convention, just before they could unmask a fraud at work in the crowd. Only the great detective Medea Thorne can find the killer. But every sleuth needs a sidekick: That’s where you come in.
  • The Missing Will: Uncle Gregory McGough has passed away...or could it have been murder? His will is locked away in a safe. The only problem is no one knows the code. Only the great detective Medea Thorne can deduce the combination and reveal the contents of the will. But every sleuth needs a sidekick. Are you up for the challenge?
  • 500 pieces each.
  • Printed in China.

Usually ships within 24 hours.

See all shipping options and costs

Shipping outside of the U.S.? You will be quoted a specific delivery timeframe at checkout, based on your destination country and the available shipping methods. See International FAQ for more info.

Sadly, we are unable to ship to APO, FPO, or DPO addresses at this time. We are working towards a solution that will allow us to resume this type of shipping.

Made from

non toxic ink, 90% post-consumer recycled grayboard, 70% recycled paper

Measurements

7" L x 9" W x 2.5" H; Completed Puzzle Measures 15.5" L x 24" W

Notes

500 Pieces

Item ID

52885

Still haven't found the details you're looking for? Check out our Product Q&A!

Try our gift finder

Customers also bought

similar categories
Great gift Fun activity Challenging puzzle Unique experience Mystery aspect Family bonding Creative design

People love this product for its unique combination of puzzles and mysteries, making it a fun and challenging gift for family and friends.

AI generated summary

  • 5 stars out of 5

    My daughter-in-law is a member of a murder mystery group and also love…

    • None
    • Rochester, NH

    read full review

  • 5 stars out of 5

    These are quality puzzle pieces that are only 500 pieces but provide a…

    • Ann the Puzzler
    • San Francisco, Ca

    read full review

  • 5 stars out of 5

    Both my wife and my friend love puzzles and murder mysterys. What a pe…

    • Wife & friend
    • Hibbing, Minnesota

    read full review

4.66
4.66 stars out of 5
based on 253 reviews
94%
of respondents would
recommend this to a friend
5 stars
198 users rating this 5 stars
4 stars
35 users rating this 4 stars
3 stars
12 users rating this 3 stars
2 stars
4 users rating this 2 stars
1 star
4 users rating this 1 star
  • 5 stars out of 5
  • None
  • verified reviewer
  • Rochester, NH

My Daughter-in-law loved these puzzles

My daughter-in-law is a member of a murder mystery group and also loves puzzles. So when I bought one puzzle for her on Christmas and a second one this Mother's Day she absolutely loved the challenge of having to solve the murder mystery to be able to then put the puzzle together. She said it was they were the most challenging and FUN puzzles she has ever done. I hope the artist/seller will make more of the same type puzzles as I would love to keep buying them for her.

  • 5 stars out of 5
  • Ann the Puzzler
  • verified reviewer
  • San Francisco, Ca

Puzzler's Dream!

These are quality puzzle pieces that are only 500 pieces but provide a visual mystery. As the puzzler only has a keyhole image of what the completed picture will be. My dad does not get out much anymore having had some falling issues and unsteady gate. These puzzles provide us an activity that is mentally engaging, that we can spend a day or a weekend socializing over. They also remind of us of his mom who loved to puzzle. Thank you for the adventure!

  • 5 stars out of 5
  • Wife & friend
  • verified reviewer
  • Hibbing, Minnesota

Bought one for my wife and one for a friend

Both my wife and my friend love puzzles and murder mysterys. What a perfect fit!

  • 5 stars out of 5
  • MJ (but not Spiderman's MJ, sadly)
  • verified reviewer
  • Grand Rapids, Michigan

cool idea - might get one for myself

I gave this as a gift for a gift exchange. Everyone was asking where I got it from! The box has a nice texture and it's cool that it looks like a book. #sweepstakes

  • 5 stars out of 5
  • Sammy
  • verified reviewer
  • Undisclosed

Gave this as a gift and they loved it!

I gave this as a gift and the recipient was really excited about it!

  • 1 star out of 5
  • Kim
  • Undisclosed

Can I give ZERO stars?

We are avid puzzlers. We just finished this puzzle last night just like the review below. We could have written their review! The "mystery" with this puzzle is that it makes no sense whatsoever and was a complete waste of time. What a joke. I REGRET buying this as a Christmas gift.

Response from merchant

Thank you for sharing your feedback. We’re sorry to hear that the puzzle didn’t meet your expectations and that the clues were more frustrating than fun. That’s certainly not the experience we want for our customers. We hear great feedback about this item, I’m sorry that it wasn’t a great fit for you. We appreciate you giving it a fair chance and taking the time to work through it. While some puzzles are designed to be challenging, they should still be solvable and enjoyable. We’ll be sure to pass your comments along to our team for review.

  • 1 star out of 5
  • Puzzled Beyond Belief
  • NJ

The answers make no sense

The puzzle itself is fine, and the idea is cute, but the answers make zero sense. Like, I don't even think Sherlock Holmes could figure it out. Even using the "clue" my partner and I spent almost a half hour trying to understand what the clue even meant. When we finally gave up and looked at the answer I was furious. Was this written by AI? Or a sadomasochist? Either way it was a waste of money and made a terrible Christmas gift.

Response from merchant

Thank you for sharing your feedback. We’re sorry to hear that the puzzle didn’t meet your expectations and that the clues were more frustrating than fun. That’s certainly not the experience we want for our customers. We hear great feedback about this item, I’m sorry that it wasn’t a great fit for you. We appreciate you giving it a fair chance and taking the time to work through it. While some puzzles are designed to be challenging, they should still be solvable and enjoyable. We’ll be sure to pass your comments along to our team for review.

  • 3 stars out of 5
  • Kindy teacher
  • WA

Bit disappointed

I was excited about giving this gift to my husband for us to do together. We love reading murder mysteries and doing puzzles so this seemed like the perfect gift. Putting the puzzle together without a picture was challenging but doable with our friend's help. The disappointing part was the mystery solving. There really weren't any clues and the one clue did not make sense. Even with the answer revealed in the envelope we were still left hanging with some closure to the story.

  • 5 stars out of 5
  • Happy
  • verified reviewer
  • Winfield

Great product! Challenging and fun!

I love puzzles and bought this for myself. I really like the challenge of a mystery and puzzle.

  • 5 stars out of 5
  • Karen the Puzzler
  • verified reviewer
  • Fort Lauderdale, FL

Soooo much fun!

These puzzles are really fun to fo! As an avid puzzler, I found them creative, intriguing, and engaging. Not really difficult, but the interactive aspect added another level. Highly recommend!

customer photos

Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.

photos from reviews

  • Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.
  • Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.
  • Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.
  • Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.
  • Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.
  • Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.
  • Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.
  • Florida

How large are the individual pieces?

Verified reply from Allison

Each piece is approximately 1 inch square.

  • undisclosed

Where is the answer to the murder?

Verified reply from Allison

The answer is revealed when you are finished the jigsaw puzzle!

  • undisclosed

Is this suitable for 20 year old or will it be too easy for them?

Verified reply from Allison

The Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle is suitable for ages 15 years and up.

  • CT

Does this have a picture of the finished puzzle to use as a guide?

Verified reply from Allison

This is a twist on the classic jigsaw puzzle! In this mystery puzzle, the full puzzle image is a secret until you complete the jigsaw because it contains the crucial clues you need to unravel the mystery.

  • CA

What's the approximate weight of this item?

Verified reply from Cassandre

It is approximately 1.26 pounds.

  • OH

How many pages of reading does each puzzle include? I have a friend who is an avid reader and loves mysteries. This could be a great gift.

Verified reply from Allison

There is one page printed page that gives the background story. The rest is in the puzzle!

  • undisclosed

Are these mysteries different from the ones in the murder most puzzling book? I already bought my dad the book and want to make sure if I buy this that they are not duplicate mysteries.

Verified reply from Allison

Both of the options for these mysterious jigsaw puzzles are also cases in the Murder Most Puzzling book.

  • Chicago, IL

How many pieces?

Verified reply from Cassandre

This puzzle is 500 pieces

  • undisclosed

are these puzzles suitable for 12 year old girl?

Verified reply from Allison

They may be a little challenging, but they are appropriate in content.

This gift is great for ...

  • Critical Thinkers Who Enjoy Games

  • Couples Who Love Puzzles

  • Friends Who Enjoy Collaborative Activities

  • Mystery Enthusiasts Who Seek Challenges

Our gifting team recommends this intriguing puzzle as a fantastic way to challenge both the mind and the imagination. It's perfect for anyone with a knack for solving mysteries! At Uncommon Goods, we have a stellar lineup of products for a wide array of interests. So whether you're shopping for a detective-in-training or someone who loves a good brain teaser, we've got you covered with unique finds that cater to every taste.

Sharing a laugh or a gasp over a good mystery is a timeless gift. Our selection is curated to bring joy and excitement to all your loved ones. Explore our extensive collection of gifts for men and gifts for women, perfect for making any day feel special. With our creative options, you're sure to find something that will make them smile—and maybe even solve a mystery or two!