Uncommon Goods | Peanut Butter Sampler | Gourmet Peanut Butter

Set your location

U.S. zip codes only
  1. kitchen & bar
  2. by food & drink
  3. condiments
Peanut Butter Sampler
Peanut Butter Sampler
customer photos

Peanut butter sampler pack? Don’t mind if I do uncommongoods

Peanut Butter Sampler thumbnail 1Peanut Butter Sampler thumbnail 2
customer photos

Peanut butter sampler pack? Don’t mind if I do uncommongoods

Peanut Butter Sampler

Created by Kathy Weed

Made from honey roasted peanuts, this small-batch peanut butter sampler includes six yummy blends.

$45.00

Delicious flavors Great gift Unique variety Fun to eat Perfect for sharing High quality

Get unlimited fast, free shipping

Perks

$14.9014-day free trial

4.88 stars out of 5 1498

Get unlimited FREE shipping (and other good stuff) with a 14-day free trial of Perks. Love it? Pay just $14.90 for your first year of membership.

Membership includes...

Free Standard shipping...

on all orders, big and small

New Perk!$10 off 1-3 day shipping...

for when you need things sooner

Members-only invites...

to Perks Days promotions

Two $5 codes...

every year (you get one every 6 months*)

*excluding free trial term

Double the donation...

to the Better to Give partner of your choice (we'll give $2 to a nonprofit partner every time you buy)

Shipping to 11220 change location

Arrives Tue, Jun 10 - Wed, Jun 11

Order within 00:00:00 with Economy shipping

If your gift will arrive late, let them know it's on the way – and worth the wait.

Handmade

Independent Maker

Made in USA

What Makes It Uncommon

If you've ever caught yourself thinking, "Wow, peanut butter just couldn't get any better," while liberally spreading it over some perfectly warmed bread, you're dead wrong, my friend. Add chocolate chips, pretzels, toffee, cherries, white chocolate, and more to the mix and you've got the type of peanut butter that's the stuff of kids'—and adults'—delicious dreams. Spread on fresh bread, dip with apples, or just enjoy with a spoon—we'll be doing the same.

  • Made from honey roasted peanuts, this crunchy, small batch assortment is chock full of sweet and salty additions.
  • Set of six different flavors; 6 oz. each.
  • Handmade by Kathy Weed in Zionsville, Indiana.

created by

Kathy Weed

“I love to envision people eating a jar with a spoon, and thinking that they are in their happy place.”

Many culinary empires begin with a recipe. Kathy Weed’s began with a lesson—her artisanal peanut butter was a way to teach her children about running a small business. The endeavor, which she jokingly terms "a lemonade stand on steroids," has since expanded well beyond the weekend farmer’s market.

Usually ships within 24 hours.

See all shipping options and costs

This item is not available to ship outside of the U.S. See International FAQ for more info.

Uncommon Perks

Get unlimited FAST, FREE SHIPPING (and other good stuff) with a 14-day free trial of Perks.

join uncommon perks

Sadly, we are unable to ship to APO, FPO, or DPO addresses at this time. We are working towards a solution that will allow us to resume this type of shipping.

Measurements

Set of 6
2.75" Dia x 2.5" H; 6 fl. oz. capacity

Care

Refrigeration not required.

Item ID

26444

Still haven't found the details you're looking for? Check out our Product Q&A!

Try our gift finder

Customers also bought

Ooma Bowl
Ooma Bowl$38.00

ships free with Uncommon Perks

similar categories
Delicious flavors Great gift Unique variety Fun to eat Perfect for sharing High quality

People love this peanut butter for its delicious flavors and unique variety, making it a perfect gift for peanut butter lovers.

AI generated summary

  • 5 stars out of 5

    He loved it! He enjoyed trying out all the different variety of peanut…

    • Babette
    • Los Angeles

    read full review

  • 5 stars out of 5

    I got this as a gift for my Dad for Christmas because he is constantly…

    • Lex
    • Middletown, NJ

    read full review

  • 5 stars out of 5

    This is DELICIOUS and GREAT combinations of Flavors. A must try for al…

    • Razz
    • Salisbury, Mass

    read full review

4.72
4.72 stars out of 5
based on 457 reviews
95%
of respondents would
recommend this to a friend
5 stars
390 users rating this 5 stars
4 stars
37 users rating this 4 stars
3 stars
10 users rating this 3 stars
2 stars
7 users rating this 2 stars
1 star
13 users rating this 1 star
  • 5 stars out of 5
  • Babette
  • verified reviewer
  • Los Angeles

Great gift for the PB lover!

He loved it! He enjoyed trying out all the different variety of peanut butter.

  • 1 star out of 5
  • cstag
  • Adirondack Mountains, NY

Leaked and Stale

Something must've happened to our batch of these. There was oil on the box when they arrived and they tasted stale. Not good at all. We ended up throwing them out.

Response from merchant

We’re sorry to hear your sampler wasn’t received as it should have been, fresh and leak-free! This disappoints us as well. · We’d like to send a replacement; we’re reaching out to get started!

  • 5 stars out of 5
  • Lex
  • verified reviewer
  • Middletown, NJ

Satisfies every craving!

I got this as a gift for my Dad for Christmas because he is constantly snacking on peanut butter. The whole house is now snacking on this sampler because they are TOO good to resist! Definitely treat yourself and order this Peanut Butter Sampler!

  • 5 stars out of 5
  • Razz
  • verified reviewer
  • Salisbury, Mass

Excellent and Yummy for you Peanut Butter Lovers

This is DELICIOUS and GREAT combinations of Flavors. A must try for all Peanut Butter Lovers. You will be hooked and "HAPPY"

  • 4 stars out of 5
  • David Boards
  • verified reviewer
  • Augusta, ME

Pretty tasty twist on peanut butter

Not the usual way one might have peanut butter, but it's a fun gift idea. We are still working through the flavors but so far, it's pretty tasty.

  • 5 stars out of 5
  • Midwestern Mom Nancy
  • verified reviewer
  • Columbus, OH

Tasty and Unique Peanut Butter Gift!

This is such a great gift for my son who is currently working in Japan and came back to Ohio for our family Christmas time. He adores peanut butter and they don't sell that in Japanese Grocery stores. So he stocks up on PB online however options are very limited! These fun flavored combos will remind him of his Midwest Roots when he goes back

  • 5 stars out of 5
  • terry
  • verified reviewer
  • huntington beach, ca

My Husband Loves Peanut Butter

My husband was so excited to see these unusual peanut butters when he opened his gift on Christmas Eve. He already sampled one and loved it!

  • 4 stars out of 5
  • MaryHB
  • verified reviewer
  • Californa

If you like peanut butter...

I bought this item for our son as a Christmas gift. He is very fit, and loves nut butters as a protein. My husband and I thought we should taste one of the six jars before gifting, at least that was the excuse. We tried the granola butter, and it was yummy. I put a piece of tissue in the missing spot, and he didn't realize the missing jar until we told him. We tasted 2 more after he opened his gift, and they were delicious. We were hoping that the company would offer the ones we liked in larger sizes.

  • 5 stars out of 5
  • Gigi
  • verified reviewer
  • Western Massachusetts

Gourmet peanut butter sampler

This was a gift to my Mom for her birthday. She absolutely loved it.I got to sample a few, wow ,really delicious 😋, if you like peanut butter or know a peanut butter lover, this is the perfect gift.

  • 5 stars out of 5
  • Randy A.
  • verified reviewer
  • Wisconsin

Wry clever flavors. Great for the peanut butter lover!

Great selection of flavors. Clever gift idea!

customer photos

Peanut Butter Sampler from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.Peanut Butter Sampler from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.Peanut Butter Sampler from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.Peanut Butter Sampler from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.Peanut Butter Sampler from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.Peanut Butter Sampler from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.Peanut Butter Sampler from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.Peanut Butter Sampler from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.

photos from reviews

  • Peanut Butter Sampler from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.
  • Peanut Butter Sampler from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.
  • Peanut Butter Sampler from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.
  • Peanut Butter Sampler from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.
  • Peanut Butter Sampler from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.
  • Peanut Butter Sampler from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.
  • Peanut Butter Sampler from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.
  • Peanut Butter Sampler from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.

  • Port Charlotte, Florida

Is there soy lecithin or sunflower lecithin or any type of lecithin in these PB butters?

Verified reply from Maxienne

The assortment contains soy lecithin.

  • Minnesota

Are all of the peanut butters gluten free?

Verified reply from Itamar

Great question! All of the flavors are gluten free except Dream Big, which has pretzels (made of wheat flour) in it, and Go Lucky, which has Rice Krispies (which contain barley malt, which contains some gluten) in it.

  • NYC, NY

Can you please tel me grams of sugar in the product? Or share a nutrition label or two? I have PB lover that I want to sent these to but too much added sugar might not work. Thank you!

Verified reply from Melise

Hello! These contain between 6 and 10 grams of sugar per 2 tbs, with a total of 9-13 grams of carbohydrates.

  • FL

What size is a serving and how many carbs/serving?

Verified reply from Allison

A serving size is 2 tablespoons with 180 calories per serving. Carbohydrate total is between 10 and 13 grams.

  • ny, ny

What is the size of the jars/quantity in each?

Verified reply from Megan

Each jar is 6oz and you will receive a set of 6 flavors. Please visit the product page to see the flavors in the set.

  • Utah

Is the peanut butter smooth? or does it have the chunks?

Verified reply from Valerie

All of the flavors have a texture due to the extra ingredients, and some are chunkier than others. None are totally smooth.

  • undisclosed

Are the jars glass or plastic?

Verified reply from Michelle

The jars are plastic.

Are they certified Kosher?

Verified reply from Valerie

This product is not certified Kosher.

  • United States

Do any of the ingredients include corn syrup, high fructose corn syrup, and/or hydrogenated oils?

Verified reply from Martin

They do not. These are made with sugar and natural peanut oil.

This gift is great for ...

  • Couples Who Love Gourmet Treats

  • Friends Who Enjoy Unique Snacks

  • Foodies Who Appreciate Small-Batch Goods

  • Adults Who Indulge in Sweet Delights

Whether you're celebrating Mother’s Day or Father’s Day, this gourmet peanut butter sampler is a delightful way to show someone you care. It’s perfect for the foodies in your life, making it an ideal choice for both occasions. For more unique ideas, check out our wonderful Mother’s Day gifts and Father’s Day gifts!

When it comes to thoughtful gifting, this peanut butter sampler truly stands out. Our gifting team recommends exploring even more delicious options in our curated collections. Whether you're looking for gifts for him or gifts for her, you’re sure to find something that will make anyone's taste buds dance with joy!

US

Ship To US