Uncommon Goods | Paper-themed 1st Anniversary Gift Ideas 2025

Perks members always get FREE shipping. Join today.

  1. gifts
  2. anniversary gifts

Paper Gifts for 1st Anniversaries

Celebrate your first year with one-of-a-kind paper gifts that add a personal touch—because standard just won't cut it for your love story!

for him
for him
jewelry
jewelry
all anniversary gifts
all anniversary gifts
personalized gifts
personalized gifts
for her
for her

    featured customer reviews

    5 stars out of 5

    Perfect Anniversary Gift!

    I bought this for my husband for our "Paper" Anniversary (1st) and he absolutely loved it! He thought it was so thoughtful and right away took it to his office to hang it up. He could not get over the quality of it either! I chose the color option and asked for it to be framed and it was perfectly done. Might have to purchase another one that we can hang at home!

    • Anita
    • Whittier, CA.
    5 stars out of 5

    Perfect 1st Anniversary 'Paper' Gift

    For those that follow the traditional anniversary gift giving categories, this is a perfect gift for the 'paper' category of the 1st anniversary. It almost serves as a scrapbook in which you can add pictures, add anecdotes of the anniversary celebration, you add entries about your likes, dislikes, and your goals for the upcoming year. It is really a cool gift to do together and something that will always be a great gift to return to as you fill it out every year. Also highly suggest getting your names added to the cover! A great touch!

    • Skipper
    • Dania Beach, FL
    5 stars out of 5

    Really Special Gift

    I purchased one of these Custom Anniversary Books for my parents for their 50th wedding anniversary. It is a beautiful gift; the first page is the headlines from the day they were married and then every year after. You can really see the passage of time - not only in the headlines but also in the change in fonts, layout and then to color. The back also includes historic NYT front pages. My parents loved looking at it and reminiscing. If your recipient doesn't have a magnifying glass, however, best to include it with the gift. The font is quite small.

    • WorldsBestDaughter
    • San Diego, CA
    5 stars out of 5

    Coolest first anniversary gift!

    I love this journal. I bought it as an anniversary gift for my husband since the classic first anniversary gift is paper. There are place holders for every year to record what you did to celebrate your anniversary, favorite music/TV/movies/etc. that year, what's happening in the world, and a place for general notes. When we are 100 years old, this will be a neat token to give to our kids or grandkids!

    • Kimpossible
    • Indiana
    5 stars out of 5

    Excellent wedding present

    This book makes a great wedding gift. The quality is very nice and the uniqueness of the gift really made it memorable. Great idea for couples at any point in their relationship.

    • Always looking for a great gift
    • Newark, DE
    5 stars out of 5

    Perfect Wedding or Anniversary Gift!

    An absolute perfect gift to my wife on our 1st anniversary! She loves it and was blown away by how unique it was. I might make this my go to wedding gift to friends and family who would be tired of the same old same old. (and even if everyone I know has one, it will still be unique to that couple!) Only question now is where to hang it!?!

    • A Keen Eye
    • Philadelphia, PA
  • Item not in your wishlist
    Intimacy Card Deck$25.00
    4.9 stars out of 5 16
  • Item not in your wishlist
    The Anniversary Journal$95.00
    4.8 stars out of 5 68
  • Item not in your wishlist
    CustomizableI Want to Hold Your Hand$75.00 - $125.00
    5 stars out of 5 3
  • Item not in your wishlist
    CustomizableLove Across States 3D Art$36.00
    5 stars out of 5 8
  • Item not in your wishlist
    CustomizableCustom Love Boat Portrait$75.00 - $125.00
    4.9 stars out of 5 16

    • Under $50

back
next

1 - 30 (of 30 items)

What are they into?

Select all that apply

Anything else?

Shop our suggestions

Celebrate that fabulous first trip around the sun together with gifts that are as unique as your love story! Whether you're shopping for your partner, a best friend, or a couple just starting their happily ever after, our collection of paper gifts is perfect for those who appreciate a thoughtful twist on tradition. These one-of-a-kind treasures bring a personal touch, making them delightful surprises for anyone who’s ready to mark this special occasion in style.

Why paper, you ask? This timeless material symbolizes the delicate beginnings of a new journey—it's all about creativity and possibilities! As you commemorate this milestone anniversary, our paper gifts speak to the idea of building a life together, page by page. Here’s to sharing stories, laughter, and a few unforgettable moments, all wrapped up in a gift that'll make you smile. Cheers to love, laughter, and the adventures that lie ahead!

Shop for anniversary gifts

Which anniversary are you shopping for?

What makes us uncommon

forever returns

forever returns

if you don't love it, return it anytime

free shipping

free shipping

for Uncommon Perks members

independent makers

independent makers

creating innovative designs

better to give

better to give

over $3 million donated

B corp

founding b-corp

since 2007

no leather, featers, or fur

No leather, feathers, or fur

since our founding in 1999

Christmas Support FAQs

  • Can I send a Christmas gift to someone else's address?
    • Yes, you can ship gifts directly to another recipient's address during checkout. The packing slip won't show any pricing, and your free message will be included.
  • What are the shipping deadlines for Christmas?
    • Shipping deadlines depend on the method you select—Economy can take 3–7 business days, while Express arrives in 1 business day. During checkout, you'll see the estimated delivery date for your order to ensure it arrives before Christmas.
  • Can I choose expedited shipping for Christmas gifts?
    • Yes, faster options like Preferred (3 days), Expedited (2 days), and Express (1 day) are available at checkout. You'll see the estimated delivery date before placing your order so you can pick the timeline that works best.
  • Do you ship Christmas gifts internationally?
    • Yes, international orders are available and processed through ESW with tracking included. Custom and made-to-order items may ship separately, and estimated delivery dates are shown during checkout.
  • Will tracking be provided for Christmas orders?
    • Tracking is provided on all our placed orders. You can check the status of your package on our order on our Order Lookup page.
  • Can Christmas gifts be returned after the holiday?
    • Yes, most Christmas gifts can be returned at any time since there's no set time limit on returns. The only exceptions are fine jewelry, live plants, and succulents, which must be returned within 30 days of delivery. Just start a return through our online portal and we'll process it once it arrives at our warehouse.
  • Can I get my gift custom wrapped for Christmas?
    • Yes, most items can be gift packaged for an additional fee, and you can even group multiple items into the same package. Our gifts are wrapped in an Uncommon Goods reusable drawstring bag. Please note that custom-made items and international orders are not eligible for gift packaging.
  • Do Christmas gifts come with a gift receipt?
    • Every order includes a packing slip without pricing details, which serves as a gift receipt. Your purchase confirmation email will contain all payment information instead.
  • Can I add a personalized note to my Christmas gift?
    • Yes, you can include a complimentary personal message of up to 250 characters on the packing slip, or add it to a card with gift packaging for $5.95. The message can be reviewed and edited during checkout.
  • Do you offer personalized gifts in time for Christmas?
    • All in-stock customizable gifts from our website can be purchased during the holiday season. Shipping deadlines depend on the method you select—Economy can take 3–7 business days, while Express arrives in 1 business day. During checkout, you'll see the estimated delivery date for your order to ensure it arrives before Christmas.
  • How do I know if a Christmas gift will be back in stock?
    • If a Christmas gift is on backorder, you'll see the expected shipping date right on the product page and during checkout. For items that are out of stock, you can enter your email to be notified when they're available again—usually within 2–4 weeks. If an item is marked discontinued, it won't be restocked. See more information on our product availability page.