Breast Cancer Awareness Month: Select Breastcancer.org at checkout and we'll double our Better to Give donation—at no cost to you. shop & support

Item not in your wishlist
Choose Your Flavors Cinnamon Roll Dozen
Choose Your Flavors Cinnamon Roll Dozen
Choose Your Flavors Cinnamon Roll Dozen

Choose Your Flavors Cinnamon Roll Dozen

Created by Rebecca Nagy

Twelve rolls, many flavors, zero wrong choices—this box is cinnamon roll heaven, your way.

$55.00Earn $5.50 in Rewards with Perks

Handmade

Independent Maker

Made in USA

What Makes This Choose Your Flavors Cinnamon Roll Dozen Uncommon

Are visions of cinnamon sugar and frosting dancing in your head? Then this is your lucky day, because Rebecca Nagy is here to make those cinnamon roll dreams come true. Choose your four favorite flavors from Rebecca's droolicious menu of 15 varieties. Every one is a hand-rolled, gooey masterpiece inspired by a 70-year-old family recipe. Baked to perfection in small batches with real butter and rich brown sugar, each roll delivers that warm cinnamony magic in every single bite.

  • Includes 12 jumbo cinnamon rolls with your choice of up to four flavors (you'll receive three rolls per flavor).
  • Mix and match from your choice of 15 unique flavors (see the dropdown menu for the full list).
  • Crafted with a special double-rise technique for next-level softness and tender layers, with rich fillings that make every bite taste like the center of the roll.
  • Ships directly from the bakery to your door—just heat, frost, and indulge.
  • Handmade in Michigan.

created by

Rebecca Nagy

Rebecca Nagy is the heart behind the Michigan bakery where cinnamon rolls celebrate tradition, connection, memories, and special moments. After retiring from a nursing career, Rebecca followed the advice of friends and family who'd always told her she should open her own bakery. Inspired by her mother's original recipe and a dream to bring joy through food, Rebecca teamed up with her daughter Rachelle to turn a family favorite into a national sensation. Her rolls are jumbo-sized and handmade with a 70-year-old recipe that's never been matched. "We do one thing and we do it the best," she says. "Nobody else makes a cinnamon roll that compares to these."

This item includes perishable food, which can only ship via Preferred, Expedited, and Express

This is a made-to-order item that ships directly from the maker. If you order today your item will ship no later than 10/28/2026.

Items that are made to order or oversized can't be sent in a Gift Bag. Instead, you can include your Gift Message on the shipment's packing slip. 

At this time, this item cannot be shipped to APO/FPO addresses, P.O. Boxes, or to U.S. Territories including Minor Outlyling Islands. Contact custom@uncommongoods.com with any questions.

This item is not available to ship outside of the U.S. See International FAQ for more info.

Made-to-order and customized items are not returnable unless damaged or defective. See our return policy for more details.

What are the cinnamon rolls' measurements?

Each Pastry 3.5" Diameter

How do you care for the cinnamon rolls?

Microwave safe; Heat a single roll in the microwave for 20-30 seconds, frost, and enjoy!

Item ID

61890

Still haven't found the details you're looking for? Check out our Product Q&A!

Customers also bought

Also by Rebecca Nagy

4
4 stars out of 5
based on 3 reviews
67%
of respondents would
recommend this to a friend
5 stars
2 users rating this 5 stars
4 stars
0 users rating this 4 stars
3 stars
0 users rating this 3 stars
2 stars
1 users rating this 2 stars
1 star
0 users rating this 1 star
  • 5 stars out of 5
  • Carie
  • verified buyer
  • verified reviewer
  • California
  • Submitted as an incentivized review

Will definitely buy again

I just can't make cinnamon rolls. They never come out right. Most premade cinnamon rolls are too sweet (even without icing) and/or have a bunch of additives. The true mark of a great cinnamon roll is that it will taste great without any icing or frosting. These definitely fit that bill. The best part is that I could put on as much or as little icing as I wanted. I tried the peanut butter even though I expected not to like it, and it turned out to be my favorite. The cinnamon wasn't overwhelming. The classic buttercream was better than I usually encounter. I am definitely buying this again. My family's Christmas tradition was Pillsbury cinnamon rolls on Christmas morning. Not anymore! These will be the new tradition. #sweepstakes

  • 5 stars out of 5
  • 10lee
  • verified buyer
  • verified reviewer
  • Milwaukee, WI
  • Submitted as an incentivized review

Really tasty!

Almost as good as Cinnabon! Easy to heat, so many combinations to try, great for a quick treat!

  • 2 stars out of 5
  • Dagny2017
  • Undisclosed

Not As Described

These arrived in one box for the cinnamon rolls and one box for the TOPPINGS that are shipped in separate containers, not baked into the cinnamon rolls. This was disappointing - I did not think I was ordering a DIY kit. Also, several of the toppings arrived with condensation on them, leading me to believe they were previously refrigerated or frozen, but there was no dry ice or anything in the box. Unclear from tracking information how long they were in transit, so unsure whether the toppings are safe to use. When I called Uncommon Goods to ask/provide this feedback, they said they didn't know because this item ships directly from the bakery. Overall unimpressed, will not purchase again, and would not recommend.

Response from merchant

Thank you for your review. Our buying team tests every one of the new products offered on our website. We check for good quality materials, instructions, and packaging and are sorry that this item missed the mark! We'll send your feedback along to our team to include a detailed description.

customer photos

Choose Your Flavors Cinnamon Roll Dozen from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.

photos from reviews

  • Choose Your Flavors Cinnamon Roll Dozen from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.
  • PA

How well do these freeze?

Verified reply from Allison

The cinnamon rolls and toppings can be frozen for up to 1 year. Each roll can be taken out of the freezer and heated in the microwave for 35-40 seconds. All packages include heating and storage instructions for the rolls and their toppings.

Holiday shopping gets easier once you stop looking for the perfect gift and start looking for the right one. The best presents come from independent makers, and this is one of them. Browse our full collection of thoughtful Christmas gifts to see what else fits the list.

Most lists split fairly neatly by recipient, which makes them quicker to work through. Have a look at our gifts for men and our gifts for women to fill in the gaps.