Uncommon Goods | Unexpected Peanut Butter Trio | gourmet peanut butter

We're partnering with Breastcancer.org for the month of October: Oct. 13-19, we'll donate $5 when you select them at checkout. (At no cost to you!) SHOP NOW

Skip to main content
Item not in your wishlist

Unexpected Peanut Butter Trio

Savory, crunchy, and completely surprising—this trio turns everyone's favorite spread into a bold new experience.

$42.00

Shipping to 11220change

Arrives Wed, Oct 15 - Thu, Oct 16 — order within 00:00:00

Learn more

Arrival estimate is based on Standard shipping to the zip code provided. Other ship methods with different arrival dates are available in checkout.

Free forever returnsdetails

Made in USA

What Makes It Uncommon

Think you know peanut butter? Think again. This small-batch trio takes everyone's favorite spread into uncharted (and totally snackable) territory. Each jar blends ultra-smooth peanut butter with savory seasonings and signature crunchy mix-ins for a texture-packed bite that’s anything but expected.

  • Includes three 11.8-oz. jars of small-batch, savory peanut butter made with U.S.-grown peanuts and bold mix-ins:
    • Buffalo Crunch – Tangy, mildly spicy, and slightly sweet, this flavor shines on celery sticks, roasted cauliflowers, apple slices, or even stirred into peanut noodles.
    • Dill Pickle – Bright and briny with a zingy crunch—perfect on cucumber slices, alongside cheese and mustard on a board, or dipped with pretzels and cranberry jelly.
    • Everything Bagel – Savory and loaded with crunch, this one's made for topping actual bagels, stuffing dates, layering into cream cheese sandwiches, or dressing up a slice of cucumber.
  • Crafted using a single-vessel blend method that keeps every crunchy mix-in bold and intact.
  • See nutritional information here.
  • Handmade in New Hampshire.

Usually ships within 24 hours.

See all shipping options and costs

This item is not available to ship outside of the U.S. See International FAQ for more info.

Uncommon Perks

Get unlimited FAST, FREE SHIPPING (and other good stuff) with a 14-day free trial of Perks.

join uncommon perks

Sadly, we are unable to ship to APO, FPO, or DPO addresses at this time. We are working towards a solution that will allow us to resume this type of shipping.

Need to return? Free returns are accepted forever—no time limits. Within 30 days of delivery, refunds to the original payment method will be available. After 30 days, refunds will be processed to a digital gift card. See our return policy for more details.


Measurements

3 jars
Each Jar 11.8 oz

Care

Keep in cool place.

Ingredients

Everything Bagel
Peanut Butter (Peanuts, Salt), Bagel Chips (Wheat Flour, Soybean Oil, Yeast, Vital Wheat Gluten, Salt, Sugar, Malt Powder Bean Oil, Yeast, V Salt, Sugar, Malt Powder (Barley Malt Flour, Dextrose, Wheat Flour), Sea Salt, Natural Flavor, Bascorbicacid), Sesame, Poppy, Caraway, Garlic, Onion, Salt

Dill Pickle
Peanut Butter (Peanuts, Salt), Dill Pickle Seasoning (Vinegar Powder (Maltodextrin. White Distilled Vinegar. Modified Corn Starch), Sea Salt, Maltodextrin, Dehydrated Onion, Sugar, Dehydrated Garlic, Dill Weed, Citric Acid, Soybean Oil, Malic Acid, Tabasco Powder (Red Pepper, Distilled Vinegar, Salt), Natural Flavor, (And Not More Than 2% Silicon Dioxide), Roasted Peanuts (Peanuts, Salt)

Buffalo Crunch
Peanut Butter (Peanuts, Salt), Buffalo Peanuts B (Peanuts, Sugar, Vinegar, Cayenne Pepper, Salt, Garlic Powder), Paprika, Salt, Black Pepper, Dehydrated Granulated Garlic, R Dehydrated Granulated Onion, Ground Red Pepper

Contains: Wheat, Peanuts, Soy, Sesame. Manufactured In A Facility That Also Processes: Milk, Egg, Almond, R Cashew, Hazelnut, Macadamia Nut, Pecan, Pistachio, Walnut, Wheat, Peanuts, Soy, Sesame

Item ID

61724

Still haven't found the details you're looking for? Check out our Product Q&A!


5
5 stars out of 5
based on 1 reviews
100%
of respondents would
recommend this to a friend
5 stars
1 users rating this 5 stars
4 stars
0 users rating this 4 stars
3 stars
0 users rating this 3 stars
2 stars
0 users rating this 2 stars
1 star
0 users rating this 1 star

Excited to try

Bought their sweet version before but not the savory. I am so excited to try them. Especially the buffalo peanut butter on celery!